一、理论争鸣的得失关于语文教育人文性的争鸣发轫于上海《语文学习》１９８７年第８期刊载的陈钟梁先生的一篇文章《是人文主义，还是科学主义》。陈先生认为：“现代语文教学发展的趋势，很可能是科学主义思想与人文主义思想的结合。”这场争鸣的焦点是语文学科的性质，... I. The Pros and Cons of the Theoretical Controversy The contentious debate about the humanities of Chinese education originated in an article by Chen Zhongliang, “Humanism or Scientism,” in the 8th issue of the “Language Study” in Shanghai in 1987. Mr. Chen believes: “The trend of the development of modern Chinese teaching is probably the combination of scientism and humanism.” The focus of this debate is the nature of the language discipline,...