论文部分内容阅读
认真解析嫖宿幼女罪的存废历史与争鸣立场,探索出这个罪名不存在是将卖淫幼女作为“不良少女”歧视对待,是对嫖宿幼女者的不当轻罚与放纵,是对卖淫幼女性自主能力的不当承认与弱化保护等非正义立场。如果这些废除理由的正当合理与否不被认真辨析,这个罪名的废除也并不会使罪名存废的争鸣戛然而止。嫖宿幼女罪与奸淫幼女罪属于竞合关系,坚持“从特兼从重”处罚原则便可以实现对嫖宿幼女行为定罪量刑的合情与合理,无须借助于废除这个罪名或其他重构方案的辅助。保留嫖宿幼女罪彰显了法律父爱主义对卖淫幼女特殊保护的合理立场,满足了刑事立法节俭性与稳定性的合理要求,其法定刑配置彰显了一般预防必要性增大合理审视的刑事立法技术。
Careful analysis of the history of the crime of dating girls’ sits and voices and debate the position to explore the existence of this charge does not exist is the prostitution of young girls as “bad girl ” discriminatory treatment, is undocumented young girls prostitution and indulgence, is a prostitution Improper recognition of juvenile self-determination and weakening of protection and other unjust positions. If these justifications for abolition are not properly justified, abrogation of this offense will not abruptly stop the contention of abstention. Adolescent girls sex crimes and adolescent crimes belong to the co-opetitive relationship, adhere to the “from the special and from the heavy ” principle of punishment can be achieved on the whoring girl act conviction sentencing is reasonable and reasonable, without resorting to the abolition of this charge or other reconstruction Aid to programs. Preserving the crime of whoring girl and underage shows the reasonable position of legal father-in-law on the special protection of young girls in prostitution, meets the reasonable request of frugality and stability of criminal legislation, and its statutory sentence allocation shows the necessity of general prevention to increase the criminal legislation of reasonable examination technology.