叶圣陶的“阅读是写作的基础”这一观点,潘新和教授有很大的不满。他说:“直到今天仍试图用叶圣陶教育思想和传统语文教育观念来统一语文界,这既是语文界的耻辱,也是对语文界的羞辱。”最近又读到一篇批判叶老的文章《写作与阅读关系再认识》(以下简称《写作》,《语文教学通讯》B刊2015年5期),作者对叶老的文章误读很深,说什么“阅读是写作的一个基础,但不是唯一的基础,甚至是很次要的一个基础。叶老不经 Ye Shengtao’s ”reading is the basis of writing,“ this point of view, Professor Pan Xinhe have a lot of dissatisfaction. He said: ”Until today, attempts to unify the Chinese language community with Ye Shengtao’s educational thinking and traditional Chinese education concepts are not only a shame in the language world, but also a humiliation to the language world.“ Recently, ”The Recognition of the Relationship Between Writing and Reading“ (hereinafter referred to as ”Writing“, ”Journal of Chinese Teaching Communication“ B 2015 5), the author misunderstood Ye’s article deeply and said that ”reading is a foundation of writing, But not the only basis, or even a secondary basis