红军长征途中在岷江上游建立的以茂县为中心的革命苏区,是按照中央遵义会议后在川西北建立根据地的既定战略所建立的。红军在大小金川地区建立的苏区,是按照中央决定创建的川陕甘苏区的一部分,与红四方面军等南下无因果关系,其历史贡献应充分肯定。根据文献资料,红四方面军等南下的战略计划早在“芦花会议”前已经制定并向中央表明,南下动因主要应是四方面军在战略意见出现重大分歧的情况下,为实现原定战略方针采取的军事行动。 The Revolutionary Soviet Area centered on Mao-mao established on the upper reaches of the Minjiang River during the Long March of the Red Army was established in accordance with the established strategy of establishing a base in the northwestern Sichuan after the Central Zunyi Conference. The Soviet Area established by the Red Army in the area of ​​Jinchuan in size was part of the Gansu-Gusu Districts created by the Central Government and unassociated with the Red Army such as the South Fourth Army. Its historic contribution should be fully affirmed. According to the literature and materials, the strategic plan for the south under the Fourth Red Army has been formulated and promulgated to the Central Government before the “aloe meeting” as early as possible. The main cause of the southward movement should mainly be that under the situation where there are major differences of strategic opinions among the four front armies, The military action taken by the guidelines.