论文部分内容阅读
猫王案(Katzenkonigs-Fall)是德国联邦最高法院1988年9月15日作出的判决,即刑四庭1988年第352号(BGH vom 15.09.1988-4 StR 352/88)。一审法院为波鸿地方法院,提交最高法院审判的争议点是:在犯罪工具者(der Tatmittler)产生一个可避免的禁止认识错误(vermeidbare Verbotsirrrum)的情况下,如何界定间接正犯(mittelbarer Taterschaft)和教唆犯(Anstiftung)。一、基本案情地方法院以谋杀罪未遂判处被告人H和P终身监禁,被告人R九年有期徒刑并命令将其收容于精神病院。在上诉中,被告人指控该判决违反了实体
The Katzenkonigs-Fall is the verdict of the German Federal Supreme Court of September 15, 1988, namely Criminal Court Chamber No. 352 of 1988 (BGH vom 15.09.1988-4 StR 352/88). The first instance court in Bochum, the point of dispute before the supreme court, is how to define the mittelbarer Taterschaft and, in the case of der Tatmittler, a avoidable verbid mistake, Instigator (Anstiftung). I. Basic facts The court sentenced defendants H and P to life imprisonment for attempted murder. The defendant R was sentenced to nine years’ imprisonment and ordered to be admitted to a mental hospital. In the appeal, the accused alleged that the judgment violated the entity