Systematic review of oncological outcomes following laparoscopic vs open total mesorectal excision

来源 :World Journal of Gastrointestinal Endoscopy | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:qjw335471690
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
AIM: To systematically analyze the randomized trials comparing the oncological and clinical effectiveness of laparoscopic total mesorectal excision(LTME) vs open total mesorectal excision(OTME) in the management of rectal cancer.METHODS: Published randomized, controlled trials comparing the oncological and clinical effectiveness of LTME vs OTME in the management of rectal cancer were retrieved from the standard electronic medical databases. The data of included randomized, controlled trials was extracted and then analyzed according to the principles of meta-analysis using RevMan? statistical software. The combined outcome of the binary variables was expressed as odds ratio(OR) and the combined outcome of the continuous variables waspresented in the form of standardized mean difference(SMD). RESULTS: Data from eleven randomized, controlled trials on 2143 patients were retrieved from the electronic databases. There was a trend towards the higher risk of surgical site infection(OR = 0.66; 95%CI: 0.44-1.00; z = 1.94; P < 0.05), higher risk of incomplete total mesorectal resection(OR = 0.62; 95%CI: 0.43-0.91; z = 2.49; P < 0.01) and prolonged length of hospital stay(SMD,-1.59; 95%CI:-0.86--0.25; z = 4.22; P < 0.00001) following OTME. However, the oncological outcomes like number of harvested lymph nodes, tumour recurrence and risk of positive resection margins were statistically similar in both groups. In addition, the clinical outcomes such as operative complications, anastomotic leak and all-cause mortality were comparable between both approaches of mesorectal excision.CONCLUSION: LTME appears to have clinically and oncologically measurable advantages over OTME in patients with primary rectal cancer in both short term and long term follow ups. AIM: To systematically analyze the randomized trials comparing the oncological and clinical effectiveness of laparoscopic total mesorectal excision (LTME) vs open total mesorectal excision (OTME) in the management of rectal cancer. METHODS: Published randomized, controlled trials comparing the oncological and clinical effectiveness of LTME vs OTME in the management of rectal cancer were retrieved from the standard electronic medical databases. The data of included randomized, controlled trials was extracted and then analyzed according to the principles of meta-analysis using. the binary variables was expressed as odds ratio (OR) and the combined outcome of the continuous variables waspresented in the form of standardized mean difference (SMD). RESULTS: Data from eleven randomized, controlled trials on 2143 patients were retrieved from the electronic databases. There was a trend towards the higher risk of surgical site infection (OR = 0.66; 95% CI: 0.44-1.00; z = 1.94; P <0.05), higher risk of incomplete total mesorectal resection (OR = 0.62; 95% CI: 0.43-0.91; following OTME. However, the oncological outcomes like number of harvested lymph nodes, tumor recurrence and risk of positive resection margins were significant (R) (left, SMD, -1.59; 95% CI: -0.86-0.25; z = 4.22; similar to both groups. In addition, the clinical outcomes such as operative complications, anastomotic leak and all-cause mortality were comparable between both approaches of mesorectal excision. CONCLUSION: LTME appears to have clinically and oncologically measurable advantages over OTME in patients with primary rectal cancer in both short term and long term follow ups.
其他文献
【中图分类号】G633.91【文献标识码】  各种方式的生物课教学使我们形成了一整套在课堂上如何做好生物实验的一些方法和理论,根据我多年的生物实验教学谈谈引导学生生物实验课外实践的一点体会和方法。  一、根据季节选择生物实验课时。  南方尚可,北方的氣候环境具有鲜明的季节性,春夏秋冬,气温环境差异较大,生物实验课时尽量选择在大自然中容易找到的鲜活的实验材料,例如:植物种子的萌发,选择在春天播种的季
【摘要】建立和谐的师生关系,激发学习兴趣。重视教学艺术的研究,激发学习兴趣。体验数学美感,培养学生的兴趣。让数学文化滋润学生的心灵,培养学生学习兴趣。  【关键词】兴趣;激励;振奋  【中图分类号】G620【文献标识码】  数学是一门思维严密、逻辑性很强的学科。但教师对所授内容的平铺直叙,势必会给学生的学习带来不便,使学生感到所学内容枯燥无味。因此,教师要研究如何在教学过程的各个阶段启发诱导学生积
面对入世的机遇与挑战,本文提出了转变观念,改换思路,转变方式,转换思维,调整结构发展湖北棉业的思路与对策.
本文综述国内外有关植物铝毒害的研究进展,其中包括铝的形态及其植物毒性、植物铝毒害的症状、植物铝毒害的生理生化反应(包括对养分、水分的吸收和运输、光合作用、呼吸作用
【摘要】信息技术的发展为民族类地区的繁荣和教育发展提供了条件,在少数民族地区授好信息技术课对少数民族学生具有重要的意义,可以为他们打开认识世界和其他民族文化的大门,本文结合本人在少数民族地区授课的一些经验供大家参考。  【关键词】民族文化 丰富 教学  【中图分类号】 G630 【文献标识码】  二十一世纪以计算机和网络技术为特征的信息技术,在社会各个领域得到了广泛应用,为了使我们的接班人适应信息
【摘要】英语新课的五种导入法  【关键词】设疑式;悬念式;歌曲引入式、  【中图分类号】G620 【文献标识码】  图画式、游戏式  “一堂好的英语课,就像一支动人的曲子,有前奏,有铺垫,有高潮,还有余音袅袅的尾声。”如何科学把握四十分钟,组织有效教学,让学生“动”起来,让课堂“活”起来,使孩子们快快乐乐地获取知识,轻轻松松提高英语素质。我认为引人入胜的课堂导入是学好英语的前提。就如我们读小说的时
本文首先把安徽省阜阳市建国近53年来棉花品种更新换代划分为五个阶段,由此从棉花良繁、加工、供种等方面分析了棉种工作现状与特点,认为棉种工作总的发趋势是健全良繁体系、
生物是一门研究生命现象和生命活动规律的科学,生物课程知识点多,内容庞杂,课时数少,教学难度大,教学效果难以保证。而课堂作为教学的主阵地,它的有效性直接关系到学生学习兴趣的激
将我国棉花抗旱育种分为四个阶段,并对每个阶段的主要进展作了论述.认为抗旱育种是节水和可持续发展农业的重要组成部分,其应用前景广阔.
【Abstracts】The new curriculum standard requires elementary school Chinese teaching should be to get to the unity of instrumental and humanism, this is the basic characteristics of Chinese language tea