彭定安、马蹄疾先生编著《鲁迅和他的同时代人》一书,对鲁迅研究的重大意义和积极作用已为鲁迅研究界所公认,毋须我在此赘述.但作为“一本资料性专辑”,虽被讲评为“史料翔实”,一然而就我所见难免还有差强人意的地方.因而进一步考核订正其某些“史料”不“翔实”之处及结论的舛误,对于完善该书是一件极有意义的工作.现就所见,提出二则可供订正的地方,以求教于作者和读者. The great significance and active role of Lu Xun and his research on Lu Xun, edited by Peng Tingan and Mr. Ma Zhiji respectively, have been recognized by the research community of Lu Xun without me having to go into details here.But as an informational album Although it has been commented as “a well-documented historical fact,” as far as I can see, inevitably there are still unsatisfactory places. Therefore, further examination and correction of some of its “historical facts” are not “informative” and conclusion errors, It is a very meaningful work, and as far as we can see, we propose two places for revision so that we can seek advice from authors and readers.