关于宋代夹锡钱是铁钱还是铜钱的争论,一直没有令人满意的结果。《中国钱币》杂志86年第三期刊登的华觉明、赵匡华的评论文章和96年第三期刊登叶世昌先生的评论文章,都做了理论上的探讨、两家文章立论的依据均为《宋史·食货志》及其它有关的宋代钱币资料,均没有提供相关的实物佐证,两家却都认为夹锡钱是铁钱而不是铜钱,此论难免有失偏颇,笔者不敢苟同。下面笔者就自己对宋钱的研究和收存的钱币实物谈点个人看法。 There has been no satisfactory result of the controversy over whether money in the Song Dynasty was tin money or coins. The articles by Hua Jueming and Zhao Kuahua published in the third issue of China’s Coin Magazine in 1986 and the article reviewed by Mr. Ye Shichang in the third issue of 96 are all theoretically discussed. Both articles are based on “ Song Shi Foodstuffs ”and other related Song Dynasty coin data, did not provide relevant evidence in kind, both think that money is not money but not coins, this theory is inevitably biased, I do not agree. The following author on their own money on the research and storage of coins talk personal point of view.