《寻根》今年第４期，发表了谢志民、宫哲兵两位先生有关女书文字的论述。谢文《论女书构成与古越稻作文化》认为女书的形成系来自古越稻作文化。宫文《江永女书是清代的文字》认为这种文字是在清末出现。笔者却认为两种看法都需商榷，现分别评述如下。 女书及其文字并不是根据 “Roots” The fourth issue of this year, published Xie Zhimin, Gong Zhebing two gentlemen’s writings on the woman’s book. Xie Wen “On the composition of the female book and the ancient Yue rice culture” think that the formation of female book comes from the ancient Yue rice culture. Gong Wen “Jiang Yongnshunsi is the Qing Dynasty text” that this kind of writing is in the late Qing Dynasty. The author believes that both views need to be discussed, are respectively as follows. Female book and its text is not based