作为研究资料,拍卖会的作品能不能用?这几乎是一个不需要回答的问题。就像若有人问私人饭店的酒席能不能吃,大家都会骂他傻。但今天这个问题,值得花费一篇短文来认真回答。最近,我给一家杂志写的文章,用到清代某书家的作品,为了说明问题,我提供了十来件不错的图版。编辑一开始很是满意,但过了一段时间告诉我,这些图一张都不能用,因为全是拍卖会里的。我解释说:一、《中国古代书画图目》中 As a research material, can the works of the auction be used? This is almost a question that does not need to be answered. It’s like if anyone asks if the banquet in private restaurant can eat, everyone will scold him silly. But today’s issue is worth spending a short essay to answer seriously. Recently, I wrote an article for a magazine that used the works of a certain book writer in the Qing Dynasty. In order to illustrate the problem, I provided a dozen of good plates. The editor was very satisfied at the beginning, but after a while I was told that none of these figures could be used because it was all in the auction. I explained: First, “in ancient Chinese calligraphy and painting pictures”