王辉先生在1998年10月出版的《陕西历史博物馆馆刊》第一辑上著文《咸阳塔儿坡新出陶文补读》，对拙文《咸阳塔儿坡秦墓新出陶文》，①提出了很多意见，发表了自己独到的见解。读后很受启发，收获是多方面的。然而，在接受王文精辟见解的同时，对有些观点则不敢苟同，今写出自? In his first series, Shaanxi Museum of History and Science, published in October 1998, Mr. Wang Hui wrote a book titled “Xinliangtaier Po” in Xi’eryang, Made a lot of opinions, published his own unique insights. After reading very inspired, harvest is multifaceted. However, while accepting Wang Wen’s brilliant insights, he disagreed with some of his views and wrote it now.