《江行初雪图》卷被学界普遍认为作于南唐为蔡先生的论点是站不住脚的。是论证南唐画院存在的重要证据,然据我以前考察,实则该画应为宋初画院学生赵斡临摹王维《捕鱼图》之习作。蔡星仪先生对我的上述论点提出了详细商榷意见,本文一一覆案后,认 The book “The First Snowfall in Jiang Xing” was generally considered by the academic community as untenable as the argument made by Mr. Cai in the South Tang Dynasty. Is to demonstrate the existence of Nantang Academy of Fine Arts evidence, but according to my previous inspection, but in fact the painting should be the Academy of Fine Arts students in the early Zhao copy Wang Wei “fishing map” of the work. Mr. Cai Xingyi on my above argument put forward a detailed discussion, this article one by one after the case, that