Urgent Need to Improve the Quality of Case Report in Traditional Chinese Medicine: Assessment on Rep

来源 :Chinese Journal of Integrative Medicine | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:han8349
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
Objective: To survey the reporting quality of traditional Chinese medicine(TCM) case reports published in recent years and understand the common problems. The assessment results would lay the foundation for the development of recommendations for case report in Chinese medicine. Methods: This survey determined the reporting quality of cases with Chinese herbal decoction, Chinese proprietary medicine, acupuncture, moxibustion and other traditional therapies published in 20 core medical journals of China by searching the China Academic Journals Full-text Database from 2006 to 2010. Fifty survey items in 16 domains were used to determine the reporting quality. One point was assigned to each item(Yes=1 point; No=0 point), and total score was 50 points. The domain of treatment was assessed independently, ranging from 2 to 9 items for different TCM interventions. Results: The total of 1,858 case reports, covering 3,417 cases were included to analyze from 13 out of 20 core medical journals of China. There were 74.8% of them did not identify the nature of study in title, while 73.9% did not comprise an abstract. Incomplete reporting was found in discussions/comment, and only 38.9% had made recommendations or take-away messages. Figures and tables were infrequently used. Three cases cited the full names of patients, but without declaring that any consent was obtained. Over 90% reported the symptoms and signs of TCM, and characteristics on tongue and pulse, but less than 50% did mention other medical history and diagnostic rationale. More than 90% treatments of the included cases were herbal decoction, with clear reporting on the ingredients and dosages. However, the reporting rate of the dosages of each ingredient was just 48.4%. Almost none reported the quality control of crude herbs, manufacturers and lot numbers of herbal proprietary medicine. Besides, advices and precautions on diet, emotions and living were rare to be illustrated. Conclusion: Systematic reporting recommendations are urged to develop for improving the contents and format ofcase reports in TCM. Objective: To survey the reporting quality of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) case reports published in recent years and understand the common problems. The assessment results would lay the foundation for the development of recommendations for case report in Chinese medicine. Methods: This report determines the reporting quality of cases with Chinese herbal decoction, Chinese proprietary medicine, acupuncture, moxibustion and other traditional therapies published in 20 core medical journals of China by searching the China Academic Journals Full-text Database from 2006 to 2010. Fifty survey items in 16 domains were used to determine the reporting quality. One point was assigned to each item (Yes = 1 point; No = 0 point), and total score was 50 points. The domain of treatment was assessed independently, ranging from 2 to 9 items for different Results: The total of 1,858 case reports, covering 3,417 cases were included to analyze from 13 out of 20 core medical journals of China. There were 74.8% of them did not identify the nature of study in title, while 73.9% did not comprise an abstract. Incomplete reporting was found in discussions / comment, and only 38.9% had made recommendations or take-away messages. Figures and 90% reported the symptoms and signs of TCM, and characteristics on tongue and pulse, but less than 50% did mention other medical history and diagnostic rationale. More than 90% treatments of the included cases were herbal decoction, with clear reporting on the ingredients and dosages. However, the reporting rate of the dosages of each ingredient was just 48.4%. Almost none reported the quality control of crude herbs, manufacturers and lot numbers of herbal proprietary medicine. Besides, advices and precautions on diet, emotions and living were rare to be illustrated.ndations are urged to develop for improving the contents and format ofcase reports in TCM.
其他文献
淮阳“泥泥狗”:远古文化的“活化石”王爱平十年前,在1984年的中国民间工艺展览会上,一批风格独特、色彩奇丽、造型古朴的泥制玩具,引起了国内外观众和专家们的注意。这些五彩缤纷、
<正> 唐寅(1470~1523年),字子畏,另字伯虎,晚号六如居士,江苏吴县人。他是明代中期吴门画派的重要成员之一。唐寅幼年时才智早熟,很早就显露出绘画上的天赋。他的绘画师法周臣,追溯至李唐、刘松年诸家,与当时的文人画家们所偏好的元代大师和董巨山水的传统有明显的区别,以细秀温润的笔法入画,兼有文人画家的风流洒脱和职业画家的严谨缜密。善于山水仕女。他的同年、同学文征明对他的画有很高的评价:“子畏画本笔墨兼到,理趣无
北胥鞬新考周轩关于北胥,古今学者多有考证。本文试作新考,以求教于大家。“北胥”这一地名,见于班固的《汉书·西域传·总序》,原文如下:至宣帝时,遣卫司马使护鄯善以西数国。及破
图书馆自动化的发展是图书馆事业再度辉煌的基础和中心 ,图书馆自动化管理系统在我馆的开通 ,是适应时代进步的要求 ,是迈向现代化图书馆的第一步 ,它的意义重大而深远 The
有机磷农药(Organophosphate Pesticides,OPPs)在世界农药中具有举足轻重的地位。世界上有机磷农药商品已达上百种,特别在杀虫剂方面,有机磷类为三大主柱之一,并长年来鳌居首
大唐女服西亚风华梅中国在公元7世纪以后的300年中,服饰发生了大的变革。这在相当程度上要寻源子公元前138年和前119年张骞的两次出使西域。因为从此开辟了丝绸之路,尽管这条陆路运输线的
本研究对1995年和1996年广东省部分吸毒人群的吸毒方式与艾滋病病毒(HIV)、丙型肝炎病毒(HCV)及梅毒的感染情况进行了检验分析。结果显示:在809名吸毒者中,单纯口吸者占31.5%,静脉注射者占23.5%,两者共用者占45.0%。静
采用火陷原子吸收分光光度法,对雄性大鼠慢性铅中毒的血铅及心、肝、肾、脾、大脑、小脑、延脑、脊髓、股骨、毛、睾丸、附睾、肌肉等脏器组织的铅含量进行测定。结果表明,与
<正> 《鱼鸟图》,长178厘米、宽23厘米。纸本,水墨,现藏湖北省博物馆(见封三)。画面主体由怪石、鸟、鱼构成。怪石占画面主要位置,自左端凌空斜出,突兀奇肆。用墨线勾出轮廓,以大小横点点写石质浓淡阴阳向背,水墨华滋润泽。三只小鸟枞居石颠,或蹲驻或作回首仰视或敛足修啄羽毛,神态若有所思若有所忆若有所言,撷神写形,风采奕奕。鸟是八大山人花鸟画创作中的特征形像,八大对鸟通常作变形、夸张、扭曲处理,表情多为默想、追思、愤怒、讶异、迷虑、疑虑、迷惑,投足举喙之态,寄托了画家深深的感情。有论者言,八