论文部分内容阅读
确立沉默权制度是我国刑事司法体制民主化和科学化改革的重要一步,但是任何法律制度的引入和改进都应当建立在对其可行性进行充分论证的基础上,否则再先进的理论、制度也会在严峻的司法实践中陷入困境。沉默权制度在中国实行会不可避免地冲击我国原有的刑事诉讼价值取向、刑事诉讼程度及刑事侦查模式。笔者认为,社会并未给沉默权制度提供一个良好的制度环境和坚实的社会基础,相反,大量的负面因素还在顽强地发挥作用。因此,在当前和今后相当长的时间内,沉默权制度在我国实际上是难以实行和奏效的,因而建议沉默权制度在中国且慢设立。
Establishing the system of right to silence is an important step toward the democratization and scientific reform of criminal justice system in our country. However, the introduction and improvement of any legal system should be based on the full demonstration of its feasibility. Otherwise, advanced theories and systems Will be in serious judicial practice in trouble. The implementation of the right of silence in China will inevitably impact on China’s original values of criminal procedure, criminal procedure and criminal investigation. The author believes that the society has not provided a sound institutional environment and a solid social foundation for the right to silence system. On the contrary, a large number of negative factors are still playing a role tenaciously. Therefore, for a long time now and for a long time to come, the system of the right to silence is virtually impractical and effective in our country. Therefore, it is suggested that the system of right to silence be established slowly in China.