推荐理由与多数“著作权批判”流于口号的道德审判或是只破不立的口舌之快不同,李琛教授以缜密而隽永的学术笔调,对著作权制度的正当性、功能、对象和性质等基本理论进行细密客观的历史还原和检视反思。本书的贡献在于建设性批判,“不唯书,只唯实”的立场贯穿始终。无论是质疑“鼓励创造”功能说还是反思“人格权”性质论,作者都不是简单化的逻辑归谬或全盘否定,而是还原错位观念进入主流话语 Recommended reason Unlike most “criticisms of copyright” in moral slogans that flow from slogans or just to break the tongue, Professor Li Chen, in a meticulous and meaningful academic style, examines the legitimacy, function, object and Nature and other basic theory of the objective and objective reduction of the history of reflection. The book’s contribution lies in constructive criticism, “not only book, only truth ” position throughout. Whether it is to question the function of “encouragement to create” or to say or reflect on the nature of “personality right,” the author is not simplifying the logic of discourse or the overall negation, but restores the dislocation concept into the mainstream discourse